Testimonials
Leasing
Operator Manuals
Classifieds
Privacy Policy
Shipping Policy
Hurricane Katrina

It has come to our attention that our competitor Northtech Machinery is quoting their double sided planers with a direct comparison with our machines. This is not surprising to us since our planers are among the most advanced and best built on the market. What is surprising to us is the level of deception that is being used by Northtech to market their planer. Normally we expect some level of spin from our competitors in their marketing practices, which is acceptable, but we can not overlook the outright false statements and level of deception used by Northtech in the promotion of their machines against ours. .

We have been given a copy of Northtechs quotation with comparisons between Northtech’s NT610XL and our Extrema XP-225. In most cases, comparisons are not between these two planers, and sometimes not an Extrema planer at all! Northtech would lead the customer to believe that he was getting the features shown in these comparisons, but in fact these features weren't on the planer he was talking about at all!

Northtech quotes the XP-225 vs the NT-610XL double side planer


Northtech Double Sided Planer Specifications NT-400XL
Specs on NT-400XL
Specs on NT-610EL Planer
Here are pictures of the first three pages of the quote. Clearly, Northtech is specifically quoting the NT-400XL (16" wide planer) or the NT-610EL (24" wide planer)

 

Northtech features vs Extrema Planer Northtech continued

Northtech says Extrema Planer is LighterNorthtech convinently shows the weight of their 610XL equipped with higher 30/30 horsepowers against our Standard XP equipped with standard 25/20 horsepowers. If they would compare our similar machine the weights would be more similar.

 

Northtech states the incorrect cutterhead motor rpm
Northtech says that Extrema machines use 3600 RPM motors on our XP-225 and Northtech uses the 1720 RPM motors. In fact our XP-225 double surfacers use the same 1720 RPM motors as does Northtech. Even if we did use the 3600 rpm motors this should not be an issue. This is not true statement and an attempt by Northtech to make their machines look better.

 

Northtech states the incorrect number of belts on the Extrema Planer
Northtech states that they use 6 cog type drive belts on their 610XL and Extrema uses 4 standard v belts on the XP-225. The first part of this statement is deceptive and the second part is just not true. Extrema uses 5 drive belts on the XP-225 and Northtech does use 6 belts, but they are comparing it to their higher horsepower double surfacer. Extrema does not have a higher horsepower XP-225. This would be very easy to just add more horsepower but we chose to make a heavier duty series of machine to handle this type of horsepower. It is our Magnum Series.

 

Northtech misrepresents the value of cogged belts versus v-belts
Northtech uses cog type belts and Extrema uses standard v-belts. This is correct, but deceptive. The use of cog type belts is just a gimmick that Northtech is using to promote their machine. They say that it gives a 60% improvement which is just not true. In fact Gates Rubber Company technical information library states that the efficiency of cogged belts over standard belts is less than 1%, and will just result in an increased cost. This is the reason Extrema uses standard v-belts. When we design any machine we heavily rely on “cost vs benefit” This is only a gimmick from Northtech with no benefit to the customer. We do use standard belts. We believe in using as many standard components as possible to lower the operation cost of our machines and availability of parts for years to come.
Gates, a leading manufacturer states that actual performance increase in cogged belts is minimal if any

 

Northtech states that their pulley is at least 24
Northtech states that their motor pulleys are twice the diameter as the motor pulley used on the XP-225. Well our motor pulley diameter is a hefty 12”. Does this mean that Northtech's motor pulley is 24” in diameter. This is not true. 24” diameter would be the size of a car tire. But anyway this is just another attempt to make their machine look better.

 

Northtech says that their bearings are bigger than Extrema bearings
A picture of the XP-225 bearings being measured at 1.572 inchesNorthtech says that their bearings are of heavier duty. In fact our bearings are world reknown SKF brand made in Italy, ZC3 motor grade quality, #6308. They also state that their cutter head shaft size is larger. They even show a photo of our shaft being smaller. This is a deceptive act because they show the end of our shaft that is cut down for a handle and is not the larger part near the cutter head that the bearings are fit to. Northtech states that their shaft size is 1.575”. In fact this is the exact same size as the Extrema XP-225. Our shaft size is also 1.575”

Continue to Page 2 - Page 3 - Page 4

New Dust Collection Products from Extrema

Extrema now has Typhoon Dust Collectors.
What's with all the updates?

See what's been changed or added to the site.
New Tablesaws from Extrema

10 and 12 inch tablesaws are now available.
Toll Free: 1877-398-7362
Alternate Numbers: 225-567-3867, 225-567-3851, 225-567-9435
Fax: 225-567-2966
© 2004 Extrema Machinery Company, Inc. All rights reserved.
Email the Webmaster